Heat from a pan rises as a plume that widens as it climbs. Against a wall, the plume can only spread three ways, and the wall itself steers it upward into the canopy. Over an island it fans out in every direction, and any movement of air in the room — a door swinging, someone walking past, an air conditioning register blowing across the counter — pushes it sideways before it ever reaches the filters.
Tall ceilings add a second difficulty. When there is a lot of height above the cooktop, it is tempting to hang the hood higher so it sits well in the room. Every hood's installation guide sets a mounting height range above the cooking surface, though, and a canopy fixed above that range misses part of the plume however strong its blower. The extra height is meant to be bridged with a chimney extension, not with empty air.
None of this makes an island hood a poor choice. It means the margin for a good result is narrower, and that a small loss of performance — baffles packed with grease, a damper that no longer swings fully open, a blower turning slower than it should — shows up sooner over an island than it would against a wall. That is why the first question we ask is simple: did it use to work better?